|
HALLANDALE BEACH, Florida: On November 4, 2009, Patti Englander Henning, a judge of the Florida Seventeenth Circuit Court, ruled in favor of the City of Hallandale Beach, Florida in a case the city had brought against blogger Mike Butler.
The city sued Butler after he submitted a request for records to the city under the Florida Sunshine Law[1][2]
Butler wanted a list of recipients of an email sent by Mayor Joy Cooper on February 17, 2009 from her personal America Online account. The subject line of the e-mail was "Mayor Cooper's Update." The e-mail included attachments to three columns written by Cooper for a weekly community newspaper addressing city policies. The e-mail included Cooper's city hall address and phone number. These characteristics of the e-mail led Butler to conclude that the e-mail was a public document, even though it had been sent on Cooper's personal email account.[1]
The city responded with a lawsuit against Butler. On November 4, 2009, Judge Henning ruled in favor of the city.[3]
Butler characterized the ruling from Henning as "shocking" and said that it runs counter to an advisory opinion issued in 2007 from Bill McCollum, Florida's attorney general, which says that e-mails from public officials "that are intended to communicate, perpetuate or formalize knowledge" are public records, regardless of whether or not they are sent using a public or governmental e-mail address.
Mayor Cooper said, "You're under the assumption that he's a good guy and he's the victim. But the victim is the city commission. I feel like my privacy has been raped."[1]
| 
